Total Comments 5 | Start A New Comment

Post Info

Comment

Posted By: Omphalos Posted On: Apr 14, 2007 Views: 768	New Dune books They really sucked, but I have read much worse, thus "I was dissatisfied."
Posted By: Tleilax Master B Posted On: Dec 11, 2006 Views: 803	the poll Well, now that I am completely finished reading it, twice, I have changed my stance. I am "dissatisfied for one reason or another". Particularly the Marty and Daniel, but a number of other items as well.
Posted By: Konman72 Posted On: Dec 8, 2006 Views: 816	Poll I voted "I love them!" but it is somewhere in between that and "They are OK". Some I found very good, others were just OK. I have problems with some things but none are too intense. Though I will admit that I am not too attentive to minute details, at least when it comes to Dune, and I have never been too interested in English and grammar.
Posted By: tleilax master b Posted On: Aug 22, 2006 Views: 514	commnets summarily deleted, that I don't doubt for one minute :) Here are my feelings, short and sweet: Prequels. Thought they were OK. Definate inconsistencies, but it didn't really bother me and found some entertainment in them Legends: Not Particulary fond of them. Found them to be campy and bit fan fiction. fine, whatever. Hunters: thus far, their best effort yet. didn't try to copy frank's style, probably a good move. consistent with the characters, haven't found glaring inconsistencies, general storyline seems consistent with what I would envision from frank. only halfway through, but generally satisfied at this point.
Posted By: SandChigger Posted On: Aug 22, 2006 Views: 487	Poll comments Any comment deemed inappropriate will be summarily deleted. Edit: Where "inappropriate" means using rude and uncivil language, including unconstructive criticism of the works, unfounded speculation as to motivations, etc., or abusive statements directed at the authors (or certain dessert-dwelling parasitic insects).