Total Comments 13 | Start A New Comment

Post Info

Comment

Posted By: Would be Watcher Posted On: Apr 19, 2018 Views: 363	Except... Except you were wrong about my stance being any different if the votes would be reversed. It is plain false (a fact). Also,I do not deny Mcdonald superior economic success. I totally agree Mcdonald has FAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAR greater economic success. However, economic success is very different from superior quality of product. The same goes for argumentation. Making an argument based on popularity is a well known logical fallacy (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_populum). Your argument isn't good or bad because it is shared by the most/least people. It is good or bad because it is well constructed or not.
Posted By: Visitor Posted On: Apr 19, 2018 Views: 382	Thou shalt learn Watcher I'm absolutely correct on all topics we've discussed. You brought it up--then deny McDonalds' has been more successful than 4-star restaurants? Do you really think just because restaurant food IS BETTER that puts them above Mickey D in the grand scheme of things? NO because MD has made trillions of dollars more, simple as that. Then you covertly attempt to push politics into the discussion yet AGAIN. But I'm not going for the bait. I SAY THEE NAY!!! ;) HAVE AT THEE WATCHER!!!
Posted By: Would be watcher Posted On: Apr 18, 2018 Views: 409	Sorry What you say is simply not true. It might comfort you to think so, but that is your right to believe I'm lying if you want. If 1 billion of you say 2+2 = 5 and I'm alone to say 4, I'm alone to be right. Numbers will let Trump win an election in a democratic system, but if you believe it proves it was the best option... I'll leave it at that. I would say the same if Superman had more votes.
Posted By: Visitor Posted On: Apr 18, 2018 Views: 145	Now You listen here Watcher.... You'd (and the rest of you) would be singing a different tune right now if Supes was ahead in the voting. But he's NOT. That tells us all something that everyone doesn't drink the Blue-Boy Kool-Aid. Now if you want to personally duel this out Watcher, I'm more than willing to oblige. And stop hating on Mickey D's! To some it is a 4-star restaurant because of why? Guess what...cost! And to many that puts them ahead in the voting! ;)
Posted By: Would be Watcher Posted On: Apr 18, 2018 Views: 141	My point is... My point is, we have no way of knowing what motivated someone to vote one way or another. It tells us very little about someone's "feeling". Pretending more votes means something beyond more posters voted one way is fallacious. McDonald sells more food and nobody sane would argue they make better food than your local 4 star restaurant. The quality of your argumentation is what matters. I wish it was mandatory to vote but it is not.
Posted By: Visitor Posted On: Apr 18, 2018 Views: 133	Um....Yes If there are more Marvel Thor supporters in these forum then it's for a good reason. And there is no prerequisite in submitting your vote. I'm just a little more vocal than most. ;)
Posted By: Would be watcher Posted On: Apr 18, 2018 Views: 128	Not really, no. The votes tells us how many fans of each there are. Nothing more. There was always more Marvel and Thor fans on this boards and I have been here since the very beginning. If the fans want to tell us how they feel, they can argue with words. Voting anonymously behind a keyboard without having to justify yourself is one thing. Arguing your point another.
Posted By: Visitor Posted On: Apr 17, 2018 Views: 138	Thor vs. Superman You are correct BK but the votes tell us how posters feel TODAY. And like boxing or any competitive sport, one fight is not the end-all be-all. That's like saying Spiderman beat Firelord because the publishers wrote that story so now it's set in stone. Folks out there aren't stupid. They read the comics and know aside from Supes popularity what Thor is capable of. And truly if a less dynamic BRICK in Doomsday was capable of killing Clark then the Hulk should at the very least be in his class.
Posted By: Bk Ray Posted On: Apr 17, 2018 Views: 160	Thor loses No amount of votes will backtrack the fact that Thor lost to Superman cleanly. This was a high profile comic, written and edited professionally and agreed on by both Marvel and DC. There is a clear love of Superman in Marvel, with his analogue beating Hulk cleanly (Superman has also beaten him). I think this is telling that Superman beats Thor's peer. Superman sits above the others. Thor and Hulk are comparable to Martian Manhunter and Wonder Woman.
Posted By: atrimus Posted On: Apr 16, 2018 Views: 230	Not bitter at all It was decided 14 years ago that Supes CAN beat Thor, not that he always will.
Posted By: Knight Posted On: Apr 16, 2018 Views: 227	Careful HammerTime Be careful HammerTime, I said something similar a while back and it angered a lot of Thor fans. As for the battle itself, I see that my comment I made some years ago still holds true. I don't care what the vote says, Superman buries Thor.
Posted By: HammerTime Posted On: Apr 16, 2018 Views: 202	Still Bitter Lot's of bitter Thor fans, I see. This was decided over 14 years ago.
Posted By: UName Posted On: Apr 15, 2018 Views: 162	Superman vs Thor Think I'll go with the one who dials it up to eleven.