Filmspotting Poll
Scarlett Johansson is: [605 votes total]

oddly fascinating/sexy, but not great (453) 75%
the female Keanu Reeves (103) 17%
an amazing actresss (49) 8%


EMAIL THIS POLL
Click Here for FREE Web Polls, Guestbooks, and Forums.


Total Comments 8 | Start A New Comment
Post Info Comment
Posted By: Blake Marshall

Posted On: Aug 22, 2007
Views: 687
That Voice

Scarlett Johansson is a capable actor and no one could argue that she isn't easy on the eyes; however, her voice leaves much to be desired. I knew there was something about her that I couldn't quite put my finger on until I saw her in Michael Bay's debacle "The Island." That voice! It sounds as if she swallows a Brillo-pad before every scene. Is she a smoker? She crosses the line of a dark femme-fatale siren into the lesser realms of a 50 year old asthmatic bartender. Can anyone else agree with me on this? Adam? Sam?

Cheers,
~Blake


Posted By: Derek J

Posted On: Aug 21, 2007
Views: 738
The problem is when she speaks...

Johansson would have made a great silent movie star--she's beautiful and her face is very expressive, but she reads dialog with no conviction whatsoever. I wonder if they could have someone overdub her lines, like they did for Andie MacDowell in Tarzan.


Posted By: Claudie

Posted On: Aug 19, 2007
Views: 898
Scarlett Johansson: Where did you go?

While I loved her in Ghost World and Lost in Translation and Girl with a Pearl Earring, lately I have found her recent performances to be quite pedestrian and of varied quality - Matchpoint and The Prestige (grating), Scoop and The Black Dahlia (uninteresting) and In Good Company (unexceptional). I love the Scarlett Johansson who played misfits and eccentrics, characters who I could sympathise and respond to.
As a sexpot or an ingenue, I don't think she's very effective and unfortunately thats that kind of roles she's been cast in lately.
Its a pity that while she's marketed as one of the sexiest, most intriguing actresses today, I now fail to find her remotely interesting or charismatic on-screen.



 
More Comments