Was Lizzie Guilty?
Who killed Andrew and Abby Borden? [855 votes total]

Lizzie Borden (590) 69%
Emma Borden (74) 9%
John Morse (24) 3%
An unknown intruder (34) 4%
Mr. Borden's illegitimate son (61) 7%
Someone else (72) 8%


EMAIL THIS POLL
Click Here for FREE Web Polls, Guestbooks, and Forums.


Total Comments 207 | Start A New Comment
Post Info Comment
Posted By: Lizzie Bathory

Posted On: Nov 5, 2007
Views: 767
Lizzie's Guilt

"Our version of the chapbook is 8.5 x 5.5 inches and about 50 to 60 pages long. It's just the right amount of space to cover the topics we like investigating, such as whether Lizzie B. did the dreadful deed, whether Queen Victoria was a vampire,"

50 pages of whether Queen Victoria was a vampire? Wouldn't that just be "no" written in very large font thousands of times to fill up all those pages?

As for the murder, the most logical suspect is Lizzie. She benefited most, she had the opportunity, and she'd know that at the time, a lady would barely be investigated for such a crime. Plus the timing is just too perfect - anyone outside the household wouldn't know the exact times when the victims would be alone. Bridget Sullivan might well have been in on it... and maybe someone could make the case that Lizzie actually paid her to do it.

What I find interesting are the different theories as to motive. Was it entirely money? Was it her parents' control over her love life? (Because of her relationship with Nance O'Neil, some theorize she was gay). Or was she just sick of Andrew Borden's notorious stinginess?


Posted By: Lisa

Posted On: Sep 27, 2007
Views: 857
Lizzie's Motives

I read a research paper that suggests that Lizzie and Emma Borden were both victims of incest. It makes a lot of sense, and explains a lot not only about the murders, but also about Lizzie's life. For example, she was a kleptomaniac who often shoplifted all around town. She had no need to steal, yet did it addictively. (Kleptomania is a behavior, or illness, if you will, that frequently accompanies molestation) Also, it could explain why neither Lizzie nor Emma ever married. And it certainly would explain why the murders were so violent and brutal, and perhaps why Emma and Bridget Sullivan covered for Lizzie, which it is widely believed that they did. Maybe they knew Lizzie did it, but felt that she was somehow justified?
Of course, we will never know. I just wanted to throw that out there.


Posted By: marlene

Posted On: Mar 25, 2007
Views: 1281
guilty

first off ever since i have been on this site about lizzy borden i have read alot on her i'am talking about her life as growing up to the murders and the trials when i read about everything so far i already put 2 and 2 together it explains all i do alot of investigating these things about people in the past please if u pay attention to what lizzy was all about and her family and u realize what went on about everything and put it all together it makes alot of common sense there is alot of motives on this issue so if alot of people would pay attention on what is going on in the story and about her life and family maybe people would realize that is was really lizzy that did it also there was a question poll about was lizzy guilty and it stated 69 percent


Pages [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ] Next Page ->  
More Comments