Supergroup UK vs. USA - Lineup #2
Which of the 2 bands above would make a better Supergroup album - UK (Sting, Page, Richards, Mullen, Martin, Gabriel) or USA ( Mellencamp, Santana, Simon, Henley, Joel, Crow) [1047 votes total]

UK (659) 63%
USA (388) 37%


EMAIL THIS POLL
Click Here for FREE Web Polls, Guestbooks, and Forums.


Total Comments 16 | Start A New Comment
Post Info Comment
Posted By: Chris

Posted On: Apr 18
Views: 36
Slaughter!

The Americans in this group would lose before they could pick up their instruments!


Posted By: Mike

Posted On: May 23, 2007
Views: 366
Vote for who you want

The top UK vote-getters at this point are:
Eric Clapton (guitar)
Justin Hayward (guitar/vocals for Moody Blues) Matthew Bellamy (vocals/guitar/keys for Muse) Paul McCartney (bass for The Beatles)
Mark Knopfler (guitar/vocals of Dire Straits) Roger Taylor (drums for Queen)
Rick Wakeman (keys for Yes)

You can vote at:
http://www.rateitall.com/t-2527-uk-supergroup.aspx

The top US vote-getters are:
Billie Joe Armstrong (guitar/vocal for Green Day)
Neal Schon (guitar for Journey)
Dennis DeYoung (keys/vocals for Styx)
Stevie Wonder (keys)
Neil Peart (drums for Rush)
Billy Joel (piano/vocals)
John Rzeznik (vocals/guitar for The Goo Goo Dolls)
Vote at:
http://www.rateitall.com/t-2528-usa-supergroup.aspx


Posted By: Jeff Kirk

Posted On: May 1, 2007
Views: 386
Seriously?

With the exception of Billy Joel, that USA band is ridiculous. They don't stand a chance against the UK........and I'm AMERICAN!

Carlos Santana vs. Jimmy Page? PLEASE!
Sting vs. John Mellencamp? Right.

Look at it this way:

Peter Gabriel....Genius.
Sting......Genius.
Jimmy Page.....Genius.

Granted, Paul Simon is well respected, but we're talking about a supergroup here.

Now, Keith Richards sucks as far as I'm concerned. I saw him in concert, and he's just embarassing. However, you offset that by sticking Sheryl Crow on the American's side. Do we not have a better option than Sheryl Crow? Seriously!

Larry Mullen Jr. vs Don Henley, I'l call that a toss-up. Both very functional drummers, but not exciting.


Pages [ 1 2 ] Next Page ->  
More Comments
Check out Supergroup Lineup #1