Total Comments 182 | Start A New Comment
Post Info Comment
Posted By: Lucie M.

Posted On: Aug 20, 2003
Views: 1389

I really don't think Sirius died. I think J.K. will somehow bring him back alive.

Posted By: Sirius Reborn

Posted On: Aug 20, 2003
Views: 1230
Sirius Died WTF

This is an outrage she purposly gets u to fall in love with sirius if you hadnt already decided he was your favorite one and then she murders him i couldnt beleive it i had to reread that page 30 times but i beleive that he will be back even if she didnt plan on it everyone ive ever asked has said losing sirius was very unkewl and unneccesary but that veil was important the voices behind it at first and loony might be a key player in whatever book hes brought back she seems the type but he didnt die by that horrible awful unruly evil #*%&$ of a witch because the color of the spell was noted in the book and was not the color of any spell to kill sirius it was something that just knocked him into the veil..... *whispers* dirty cheap shot

Posted By: Mel

Posted On: Aug 19, 2003
Views: 1314
Not really Dead?

Does anyone think that she will bring Sirius back in the next book somehow? I still am not willing to accept that he is dead. I think she will bring him back. (Especially since the majority of the readers are upset by it!)

Posted By: SY

Posted On: Aug 17, 2003
Views: 1151
Sirius Death

No it was the veil that killed Sirius, if you reread that section of the book it subtly tells you that the gateway with the veil is an old wizard execution device like a wizard guilltoine.

Posted By: Josh Jenkins

Posted On: Aug 16, 2003
Views: 1175
Who Dies

At first I thought it was Harry, i don't know why but i just did. Then i thought it would be Mr' Weasley, but I was realy suprised when it was Sirius Black

Posted By: Louise Thompson

Posted On: Aug 14, 2003
Views: 1101
who reads harry potter

ITS SIRIRUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted By: Josh

Posted On: Aug 13, 2003
Views: 1062

anyone who thinks sirius is comin' back are so STUPID! that spell that that woman that tortured nevilles parents shot the spell at his CHEST! that's what killed him, not the veil!

Posted By: Andrea

Posted On: Aug 13, 2003
Views: 1010

OMG! I swear it was gonna be arthur when i read the part about the snake... but then, my second choice was gonna be snape.. i dunno why... but like, snape isn't very close to harry, but it woulda been kool... or hagrid, that's what i thought when he didn't come back to hogwarts for, like, ever...

Posted By: Aya Lee Rose

Posted On: Aug 12, 2003
Views: 1048

I didn't really have a clue about who died in the 5th book but on the day it came out, during my orchestra rehearsal, we had a vote on who we thought it would be. Some girls who swore they'd skipped to it said it was Hermione - and I believed them. With this conviction, I never thought for a moment that it would be Sirius and when he fell beyond the veil...

Posted By: Tailz_AF_Foaly

Posted On: Aug 12, 2003
Views: 949
The death

I was always sure that Hagrid would have died in OotP.

Posted By: Meg

Posted On: Aug 12, 2003
Views: 991

I really hope Cho and Harry get together, since that little "frisky" part in the fifth book under the mistletoe. Pleasepleasepleaseplease, if J.K. Rowling reads this, it would be really cool to have Cho and Harry. Just think...Cho Potter!!!

Posted By: mishi

Posted On: Aug 11, 2003
Views: 1000
who die....

in 5th book it is sure that sirius will die but in future colin creevy may die as jonna has said that one of the bigest fan of harry may die may be he is colin because he is a very big fan of harry.i also heard that dumbledor may also die but if dumbledor dies than who saves harry fromm voldemort. i think that there is a relationship between harry and voldemort some says he is harry's grandfather some says....... if u know then tell me

Posted By: mishi

Posted On: Aug 11, 2003
Views: 1000

sirius will die in book 5th because he dies to save harry but it is awful that sirius will die he can play a great roll in future and i like him very much

Posted By: prachi

Posted On: Aug 11, 2003
Views: 1042

Sirius dead?????Nope me dont want to belive!!!He,the one of the best character whom i liked????

Posted By: sweet_weirdo

Posted On: Aug 10, 2003
Views: 1033

I CANNOT belieeeeve JKR killed of siruis, :'( I mean he had a damn horrible life and it's just really sad! Not to mention, she mentioned he was hot!

as for dumbledore! I happen to have a HUGE soft-spot for old-people- especially old wizards that happen to be the strongest and wisest and SO NICE! and always jolly- u get the idea? So in my opinion he shouldn't die. but even putting that aside i really dont figure JKR will kill him off coz if he can kill dumbledore then damn right he can kill harry any day! i mean we all KNOW dumbledore is way stronger then harry- mom's protention charm or no. so IF dumbledore is killed by voldie but harry STILL wins the day it would be kinda over dramatising, dont u think?

oh and Katrina; 'no offence intended, ofcoarse'. Stop judging ppl u dont even know let alone dissing what they SAY. really none of ur business if she says she thinks someones hot. no body asked for ur so detailed opinion... -_-'

Pages [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ] Next Page ->