Total Comments 182 | Start A New Comment
Post Info Comment
Posted By: mallory

Posted On: Aug 30, 2003
Views: 1507
DUH!

Sirius may have not died! Does falling into the afterlife necessarily mean that you're dead? I dont think so. He wasnt dead when he hit the curtain to the other side. I believe he will come back. And Harry may have broke the mirror that lets him see Sirius whenever he needs to.... but he didnt do anything with the pieces... he could possibly repair it and notice one day that Sirius is in it or something. But something will happen with the mirror. but thats just my theory.


Posted By: SAM

Posted On: Aug 30, 2003
Views: 1477
HARRY DUELING WITH BELATRIX LASTRANGE

HOW COME HARRY DIDNT GET PROSECUTED FOR USING AN UNFORGIVABLE CURSE? I KNOW THAT AN AUROR IS ALLOWED TO BECUASE OF BARTY CROUCH'S NEW RULE. BUT DUBLBEDORE WAS AROUND WHEN HARRY DID IT AND HE NEVER SAID A WORD ABOUT IT TO HARRY SO IM WONDERING WHY HARRY ISNT IN AZKABAN RIGHT NOW? HE OBVIOUSLY DIDNT DO IT RIGHT BECUASE NOTHING HAPPENED TO BELLATRIX EXCEPT THAT MAYBE SHE WAS KNOCKED OVER OR SOMETHING BUT HARRY SHOULD BE IN JAIL RIGHT NOW.


Posted By: Anita

Posted On: Aug 30, 2003
Views: 1395
dunno

o and Mel, yes I think Sirius will come back.


Posted By: Anita

Posted On: Aug 30, 2003
Views: 1336
dunno

Listen Sneha, we all realize that Sirius dies, so get a life a stop being so paranoid. Oh, and to Nicola Nye, they lived in Godric's Hollow, and obviously something strange is happening!


Posted By: Sneha

Posted On: Aug 30, 2003
Views: 1378
It is True

It is True I read The Book and I know Who Dies It Is Sirius and I am Not lying.


Posted By: Nicola Nye

Posted On: Aug 30, 2003
Views: 1462
sirius

thers no way all those ppl thought sirius was gonna die coz the was a poll up ob cbbc web site b4 the buk came out and like 1% sed sirius. but didn e 1 notice the lily and james lived in a town called godric the same name as the godric gryffindor so theres deffo a conection there and also harry has new powers to come out coz every 1 is always sayin that he has his mothers eyes the always always say this so i think they r tryin to sate the obvious. also more will come out bout albus dumbledore coz he cam speak parseltounge ( remember wen he was speakin to 2 snakes in a bowl) so sumthin strange is happenin there


Posted By: Ricky

Posted On: Aug 28, 2003
Views: 1702
Reply to STUPID PEOPLE

I am not stupid! You need to be more open. He coul still be alive! You really need to learn no to be so critical!


Posted By: Ricky

Posted On: Aug 28, 2003
Views: 1657
Replying

Too many people are lieing. Not all those people thought Sirius died, hardly anyone did. They are lying! And I agree that the book never confirmed it, she left it open so that she can do what she decides to do.


Posted By: Kimiski

Posted On: Aug 28, 2003
Views: 1579
Another death? Another character?

People are all talking about what Weasley is gonna die. J.K is rumored to have said a weasley will die and I think Ron will die. Just because he's so close to Harry. When 13 people sit down to eat the first one to rise is suppose to die, right? In the third book when 13 people sat down to eat dinner and Harry, Hermione, and Ron got up the book never said who was the first one of the three to get up. It might be one of the other two but if a Weasley is suppose to die......I don't know!!!! WAAAAA!!! Everyone's dieing!!!! :(

Now a little side note. I think that maybe one of Lily's old school friends might teach Defence against the Dark Arts either in the 6th or 7th book. Or just show up. Hey why not? Two of James old friends showed up. (hehehe) i even made a fanfic on that thought.


Posted By: Kimiski

Posted On: Aug 27, 2003
Views: 1368
Sirius Black's death

I don't think Sirius is really dead. The book never actually confirmed he died! Everyone thought it though. You say, "Well even dumbledore said he died." Well, dumbledore also thought he betrayed Lily and James Potter. They all thought Peter Petigrew was dead also. Sirius fell behind that curtain with all the shadows. And the next book (the 6th) Is named Harry Potter and The Fortress of Shadows. Hello people! Am i the only one out there that see's the connection! Fortress of shadows and that curtain with the shadows behind it? There's a clue in the book that he might return as well. Luna Lovegood told Harry: One day we'll see them again. She's referring to the shadows behind the curtains. We'll just have to wait and see.


Posted By: Elyssia

Posted On: Aug 25, 2003
Views: 1896
Thought it might be Dumbledore; and dead is dead

I actually thought it would be Dumbledore who would die. As JK has mentioned so clearly is her previous books, Dumbledore is the ony one Voldemort ever feared, and that 'As long as we have Dumbledore we'll be alright.' Dumbledore dying would allow Harry to grow as both a wizzard and a character, since he wouldn't be there to protect Harry. Harry would need to protect himself and others. But it was facinating to find out that, as per the prophecy, apparently Harry is the only one who can actually kill Voldemort. It will be neat to see how that unfolds. Neville also seems to have improved siginficantly this year. I wonder what the future holds for him...

Also, I hate to break it to all you Sirius fans (as I am a huge fan myself), but JK has said that death is permanent. Harry's parents will never come back, and neither will Sirius. I'm so saddened by his death because he was really the only 'family' Harry had. Sirius had such a difficult life, imprisioned in Azkaban for so many years, and believed by the wizzarding community to be a mass murderer and Death Eater. It's tragic, but life can be. Lest any of you thought his death was just a throwaway, in her interviews JK always said just how hard and heartbreaking is was to kill off this character. She has done an incredible job thus far in writing this series, so I am entirely willing to leave it in her hands; I look forward to reading Book 6 once it's completed. (Actually I'm just dying for it, so I'll jut have read the whole series agin, for the 8th time.
As was also indicated in Book 5, this is just the begining of the 2nd war, and I'm certain there are more deaths to follow. I just hope Ron & Hermione won't be amond the casualties. Be well, everyone. : )


Posted By: Birdie

Posted On: Aug 24, 2003
Views: 2175
Poor Sirius

I was reading it in class and when I read the part where Sirius dies, and how he was arced and stuff, I started crying and everyone started laughing at me.


Posted By: vicky

Posted On: Aug 20, 2003
Views: 2707
the curtain

katrina the curtain may not have been a logical killer but HELLO its the world of wizzards u ever seen a hippogriff or house elf? sirius dying was damn sad but it fits with poor harrys sad life.


Posted By: Janet

Posted On: Aug 20, 2003
Views: 2237
Sirius

I personelly think Sirius dying is a good thing a little. Harry won't feel any pity in killing the Death Eaters and Voldemort.


Posted By: lily

Posted On: Aug 20, 2003
Views: 1902
sirius

it was really sad....=( i cried for bout an hour...i had to read that page many many times to consider that it wasnt my imagination, and that jk had really killed one of my fav characters in the book...
i sourta had a hunch (i dont expect for you guys to believe me...like u would say "ya right she read the book...") cause i read some where on internet bout some black dog and being a Zodiac or something (i forgot the discription it was year and a half ago) ... but then i kept changing my mind....
oh well.... =)but like you guys i do so believe that he some how will come back in any way or help harry...


Pages [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ] Next Page ->